Tuesday August 2, 2005
Blue Poppies. Jonathan Falla. 11/9 Press 2001
(This review originally appeared in a slightly different version in Dharma Life magazine.)
Blue Poppies, a novel set in Tibet in 1950, tells of the love-affair between a crippled Tibetan widow, Puton, and a young Scottish radio operator, Jamie Wilsom. Set against the backdrop of the Chinese invasion of Tibet of 1950, this book smacks of authenticity from the outset. Falla is alive to texture, colour, smell and sound – from the scent of rancid butter to the precise feel of a yak’s tongue, the world he evokes is almost entirely convincing.
When the Communist army arrives to ‘liberate’ the village of Jyeko, it behaves with the most impressive military decorum; but as the book progresses things turn sour. After the murder of some Communist troops, a goatherd is tortured, humiliated and executed in the village square. The villagers take their revenge by savagely massacring of Chinese forces at a ping-pong match held in the monastery. Even the absurdity of these strange juxtapositions seems to ring true. The massacre in the monastery sets the entire village on the road to exile, with Jamie acting as their guide through the wilderness.
It is with the figure of Jamie, the radio operator from Inverkeithing, that Blue Poppies fails to convince. Part Moses, part Christ, he is a bizarre and not entirely palatable figure. The star of his sainthood blazes ever brighter as the story unfolds, his apotheosis only reaching completion when, in the wake of the slaughter of a Chinese patrol by the exiled villages, he rides off on a yak in tears. ‘Jesus wept,’ Falla tells us. Even though the people of Jyeko do not reach the Promised Land, I baulked at Jamie’s sanctity. Less human than his Tibetan companions, he seemed like some atavistic throw-back to those old colonial adventure yarns in which a single white man brings liberation to a horde of benighted savages.
Despite such misgivings, this is an exciting and moving book. Remarkably, Falla himself has never been to Tibet. That he can conjure up the world of the Tibetan plateau so convincingly is a testament to his powers of imagination. It is also a testament to the way in which a story, told with passion and conviction, can bear more truth and meaning than any amount of careful research. But then what do I know? I have never been to Tibet either.
Comments are turned off for this article.
Today's Most Popular
On Holy Books: Thursday October 12, 2006
Richard Dawkins on ethics and religious texts.
Without authority...: Tuesday August 25, 2009
Blogs, mainstream media and the idea of authority.
A Global Christmas?: Saturday December 23, 2006
Santa training academies in Vietnam? Elephants dressed as Santa in Thailand? Confucius with reindeer?
Dragons and Levitating Monks: Tuesday October 21, 2008
On the elusiveness of the miraculous.
Lose Weight: Convert to Buddhism: Tuesday September 26, 2006
Forget that diet – change your religion instead!
Music in the Sky: Book Review: Wednesday August 3, 2005
An account of the early life of the 17th Karmapa, and a collection of his teachings…
The Buddha and the Sahibs: Review: Monday August 1, 2005
Charles Allen goes in pursuit of the British orientalists
Zen and Philosophy: Book Review: Friday July 29, 2005
A review of Michiko Yusa’s impressive book on the life of Nishida Kitaro.
On Desire: Wednesday April 16, 2008
Link to online review of William B. Irvine’s On Desire
Longing for Certainty: Meditation Book Review: Friday July 29, 2005
Bhikkhu Nyanasobhano’s poetic reflections on meditation.
Zen, Brains and Making Friends With Your Own Head: 10 Nov, 2008
It’s a complicated business having a brain.
Lies in Which not Everything is False: 10 Sep, 2008
Stories – they are nothing but a pack of lies.
The Sutras of Abu Ghraib: 30 Oct, 2007
Aidan Delgado on Buddhism, ethics and the war in Iraq.
Baboon: 06 Jun, 2006
Feeling like a grumpy old baboon?
Meditation as Unphenomenology: 07 Feb, 2008
Meditation, cartography and the territory of the mind.