Monday May 14, 2007
The other night, I watched Casino Royale. Usually, I tend to be careful about the films that I watch, as I don’t have much of a stomach for on-screen brutality, but the film was classified as a 12A – which means that nobody younger than twelve can watch it without their parents’ or guardians’ consent – and so, given that my twelfth birthday was quite a long time ago now, I thought I was probably safe. Not so, however. On the one hand, the film was certainly stylish and well-made, but on the other hand, the violence was visceral and shocking, and I would have hesitated twice before giving consent to any eleven year-old to see the film.
The experience of the film was not what was most striking, however. Whilst decidedly ugly in parts – mass killings, torture, successive acts of cruelty – it wasn’t until later that I felt the effects of the film. That night, long after the final credits had rolled, I had a long succession of grim, bloody and brutal dreams all of them related, in one strange way or another, to the film. The film, it seemed, had got into my head; and it did not look like it was doing me any good.
Recently, the New Scientist published an article by Helen Phillips on the links between on-screen violence and aggression, arguing that the evidence for the link between violence on-screen and aggression off-screen is so well attested that there is scarcely any doubt that exposure to violent imagery leads to increased behavioural aggression. The article has been reprinted on the MindScience website, and can be found by clicking the link here.
Although the link is well attested, denial of the unsurprising idea that consuming images of violent acts might have a detrimental effect is everywhere. Very often, we claim that we are sophisticated enough to distinguish between ‘real’ and ‘fantasy’ violence. As John Carpenter, director of Halloween, said recently, “Real life causes this [violence], fake life does not cause it.” But putting it this way is disingenuous. It is not a matter of of distinguishing between real and fake violence, nor is it a matter of straightforward one-to-one causality in which exposure to x leads to behaviour y; it is more a question of the kind of climate of experience that is cultivated by such exposure. To be sure, exposure to violent images doesn’t make us all go out on the rampage, but at the same time it may well have effects upon the mind that are less than desirable. As the editorial in the New Scientist puts it,
Each time you bawl out a stranger over the phone, or lose it with another driver from the safety of your car, consider that these too are aggressive acts which studies have shown are more likely after repeated exposure to on-screen violence; the impact is not limited to assault and murder.
It is, I think, question of the kind of climate that we want to foster – either within our own experience or else within the relationships we have with the wider world. And if we are going to take this seriously, then perhaps we need to also look more deeply at the media we consume as a whole, considering not only the violence we see TV and in the cinema, but also that which we encounter in our addiction to the constant drip-feeding of twenty-four hour news bulletins, in novels, in music, in the books that we read and that we revere.
Comments are turned off for this article.
Today's Most Popular
Get Real...: Friday May 15, 2009
Some thoughts on tragic storytelling.
Zen and Philosophy: Book Review: Friday July 29, 2005
A review of Michiko Yusa’s impressive book on the life of Nishida Kitaro.
On Going Without Food.: Saturday November 26, 2005
Ram Bomjon, the Buddha and the virtues of a good, hearty breakfast.
Michael Frayn on Uncertainty and Motivation: Tuesday October 14, 2008
Uncertainty in Copenhagen.
On the dangers of being too philosophical...: Sunday May 9, 2010
On the closure of Middlesex philosophy department.
The Ronin: Tuesday August 2, 2005
The bloody story of a freelance samurai.
Informed Ignorance, Spinoza and Science: Sunday September 2, 2007
Spionza, ignorance, understanding – all that, and I’m still two hundred miles from the nearest decent cappuccino.
Written on the Water: Friday March 6, 2009
Thoughts on the the clamorousness of the traditions of Buddhism.
Shocking Revelations, Radical Changes and Dramatic Events: Thursday January 8, 2009
Drama, the news, and the latest shocking revelations.
Peace: Monday November 7, 2005
Is it true that non-violence cannot deal with the crises in the present-day world?
Zen, Brains and Making Friends With Your Own Head: 10 Nov, 2008
It’s a complicated business having a brain.
Lies in Which not Everything is False: 10 Sep, 2008
Stories – they are nothing but a pack of lies.
The Sutras of Abu Ghraib: 30 Oct, 2007
Aidan Delgado on Buddhism, ethics and the war in Iraq.
Baboon: 06 Jun, 2006
Feeling like a grumpy old baboon?
Meditation as Unphenomenology: 07 Feb, 2008
Meditation, cartography and the territory of the mind.